No-Proof Supplement Class Action Settlements
Updated June 22, 2026 · 5 min read · By Class Action Buddy
Short answer: Three supplement class action settlements currently accept claims without proof of purchase: Balance of Nature (all states, $30), Joint Juice Glucosamine (9 states, $150), and Cosequin Dog Joint (California only, $150). Two related OTC-drug benzene recalls — Bayer Antifungal Spray ($21) and Differin BPO ($27) — also accept attestation-only claims.
Why supplement settlements have no-proof tiers: consumers rarely keep receipts for $10-$40 supplements, and the cases typically allege deceptive labeling — meaning the harm was uniform across all buyers regardless of purchase records.
The 5 no-proof supplement / OTC drug settlements open now
Joint Juice Glucosamine
$150 maxBought Joint Juice in 9 eligible states between Mar 2009–Dec 2022. E-check to your email.
Cosequin Dog Joint
$150 maxCA residents who bought Cosequin dog joint supplements since May 2016. Up to 6 units per household at $25 each.
Balance of Nature Supplement
$30 maxBought Balance of Nature Fruits, Veggies, Fiber, or Spice since March 2019. Up to 2 products at ~$15 each.
Differin BPO Acne Products
$27 maxBought Differin BPO acne products (Daily Deep Cleanser, Acne Spot Treatment, Maximum Strength Foaming Cleanser) since Jan 2020. Up to 3 products at $9 each.
Bayer Antifungal Spray
$21 maxBought recalled Lotrimin or Tinactin antifungal spray since Nov 2015. Up to 3 products at $7 each.
What these supplement cases are actually about
- Balance of Nature. Alleges the supplements made unapproved drug claims about heart health, immunity, and energy — leading consumers to pay a premium based on FDA-non-cleared representations.
- Joint Juice. 9-state class action over glucosamine joint-health claims that lab testing allegedly didn't support. The 9 states are NY, CA, CT, FL, IL, MD, MA, MI, PA — based on each state's consumer-protection statute.
- Cosequin Dog Joint. California-only consumer-protection case over the efficacy of glucosamine/chondroitin supplements for dog joints. CA residents who bought any Cosequin dog product since 2016 qualify.
- Bayer Antifungal Spray. OTC drug recall over Lotrimin and Tinactin sprays found to contain elevated benzene levels (a known carcinogen) from contaminated propellant.
- Differin BPO. Similar to the antifungal cases — Differin BPO products (Daily Deep Cleanser, Acne Spot Treatment, Maximum Strength Foaming Cleanser) can degrade and form benzene at high storage temperatures.
Eligibility quick check
- Anyone in the U.S.: file Balance of Nature, Bayer Antifungal Spray, and Differin BPO.
- 9 specific states (NY/CA/CT/FL/IL/MD/MA/MI/PA): add Joint Juice.
- California residents only: add Cosequin Dog Joint.
If you're a California resident who has bought all 5 product lines above at some point, total max payout is roughly $384 from these 5 settlements alone.
Frequently Asked Questions
If I took a supplement that was later recalled, can I claim for health damage?
Most supplement settlements have a separate documented-harm tier for proven medical injury. But proving causation in supplement cases is difficult; the no-proof attestation tier (which compensates for the overpayment) is what most claimants use.
Why is Cosequin only for California residents?
California's Consumer Legal Remedies Act and Unfair Competition Law create a state-specific cause of action that other states don't share for this particular case. Cases like this commonly start in California and may later expand to other states.
Are dietary supplements still allowed to make health claims after these cases?
Yes, but with more careful wording. The FDA distinguishes "structure/function" claims (allowed if disclaimed) from "disease" claims (banned without clinical data). These class actions push companies to revise their marketing to stay within FDA limits.
Can I claim for both Balance of Nature and Joint Juice?
Yes if you qualify for each — they're separate settlements covering different products. If you're in one of the 9 Joint Juice states and you took both products, file both.
File every no-proof settlement in one place
Class Action Buddy auto-fills the claim form using your saved profile so you can review, sign, and submit each settlement in about a minute. First claim is free.
App Store Google Play